fresh tomato salad from TORC in Napa

The BEST THING you can do with Fresh Tomatoes (recipe)

Mediterranean Tomato Salad

by Chef Sean O’Toole of TORC restaurant in Napa, CA

This recipe for “Mediterranean Tomato Salad” with labne is best with farmers market tomatoes; the fresher the better! Watch the video to see Vince and Chef Sean of Torc restaurant make the prettiest (and dare I say, tastiest?) tomato dish you’ve ever seen. Or keep reading to get the recipe! And to get this recipe plus 5 MORE FREE, check out our “6 Killer Resturant Recipes and Wine Pairings Video Guide“!


Your tomatoes should be as fresh as possible, or as Chef Sean says, “never refrigerated”. Head to your local farmers market! The skins should be tight, and the tomato should yield slightly to the touch. As for what kind? Go for variety! Green Zebra, Purple Cherokee, yellow, red, green, polka-dot; go crazy! Different textures and sugar/acid levels are what make this dish unique.

farmers market tomatoes

the fresher the better; never refrigerated is best!

Vegetable Prep

When slicing tomatoes, go for large, fork-and-knife chunks in a variety of different sizes and shapes. Let the tomatoes marinate in olive oil, sherry vinegar, salt, pepper, and some thinly sliced fennel. The salt will tenderize the tomatoes, and allow them to take in the vinegar and oil.

sliced tomatoes and vegetables

marinate those tomatoes while you prep the rest of the salad


What is labne? Nothing more than strained (through a cheesecloth) greek yogurt. If you can’t find it at standard a grocery store, a middle eastern shop would have it. But it’s perfectly acceptable to use greek yogurt instead (especially if it’s already in your fridge!) The grated raw garlic gives the yogurt the appropriate amount of bite, while the lemon juice adds a nice acidity to the yogurt.


labne is simply strained greek yogurt


Add a few cloves of garlic, pressed and in the skin, to lots of olive oil over medium heat. Leaving the garlic in the skin prevents it from burning and getting bitter while still flavoring the oil. Add some day old french bread; bite-size craggly chunks are perfect. If they seem dry before they’re toasty, just add a bit more oil. When they are crispy on the outside but still chewy on the inside, drain them on a paper towel to remove excess oil.


sauté those with olive oil, croutons nice and toasty like


Now it’s time to wow your guests with the presentation! Arrange the tomatoes, fennel, and croutons sporadically on the plate; flat, sideways, longways, and stacked. Add a few dollops of labne and drag your spoon through them, as if to encourage the tomato to do the same. Finally add your color: espelette, fennel pollen, lemon zest, and anise hyssop. If these are a bit tough to find, sub cayenne for the espelette, and some fresh chopped sage and mint for the anise hyssop.

plating tomatoes

no science to it. plate the tomatoes first…

plating the rest

…then add your yogurt, croutons, and garnishes

Wine Pairing

Chef and I paired this with a juicy, floral, Sauvignon Blanc from Elizabeth Spencer Winery.  GET IT HERE! The acidity in the wine can stand up to the acidity in the tomatoes while cutting through the fatty yogurt, while the floral, citrusy SB notes complement all the fresh herbs and lemon.

Vince and Sean drinking Sauvignon Blanc

paired this with Elizabeth Spencer Sauvignon Blanc


finished tomato salad

done! the prettiest and tastiest tomato salad you’ve ever seen/eaten


2-4 mixed, market tomatoes

2 tsp sherry vinegar

5 tbsp extra virgin olive oil

1/4 bulb fennel, sliced thin

1 cup Greek yogurt

1 lemon

2 cloves garlic

1/4 French baguette

1 tsp fennel pollen (optional)

1 tsp espelette pepper (sub 1/8 tsp cayenne)

1 flower anise hyssop (sub 2 Tbsp fresh mint and sage)

salt and pepper to taste


1. slice tomatoes in large, various sized chunks

2. lay tomatoes flat, and add vinegar, 2 tbsp EVOO, S&P, and fennel. let marinate at least 5 minutes

3. mix Greek yogurt, 1/2 lemon zest, 1 tbsp lemon juice, 1 clove garlic (grated), and S&P

4. tear bread into bite size chunks, and sauté over medium with 1 clove garlic (skin on) and 2 tbsp EVOO, adding more EVOO if too dry, until bread is crispy

5. place bread on paper towel to remove excess oil

6. plate tomatoes, fennel, and bread sporadically around plate

7. add 3-4 dollops of the yogurt mixture

8. sprinkle with fennel pollen, salt, espelette, anise hyssop, 1/2 lemon zest, and 1 tbsp EVOO

Vino Card: Mediterranean Tomato Salad